What was almost a reality for the SWAC last year became reality for the CIAA football championship in 2009, as Bowie State University advanced to the conference championship game by way of a three-way coin flip tie breaker.
The accounting firm of Cavanaugh and Nelson administered the coin toss tiebreaker, where the three contending Athletic Directors simultaneously flipped coins; where the Bowie State Interim AD, Arlene Creek, flipped a tail versus two heads tossed by Virginia Union and Elizabeth City State.
Is it just me, or is there a way college football can solve ties without reliance on chance? Why keep track of stats like total scoring offense and defense if you can’t use them to determine which teams are better than others?
If they did, we’d likely be looking at an Elizabeth City State – Fayetteville State championship, which is what CIAA coaches predicted in the preseason. With an average margin of victory of 9.7 points per game on the year, the Vikings are .5 better than the Bulldogs and 1.3 points better than the Panthers.
There are countless other ways you could determine who is a better team between the three, but for as close as they were in 2009, you really can’t be disappointed with the upstart Bulldogs drawing the right side of the coin.
Technorati Tags: Bowie State University, Elizabeth City State University, Virginia Union University