The SIAC has released its 2009 all-conference awards, highlighted by offensive Player of the Year and Most Valuable Player A.J. McKenna of Albany State University. Willie Slater, coach of the conference champion Tuskegee Golden Tigers, was named Coach of the Year.
2009 All Conference Football Team
1st Team
| Name | CL | Hometown | Institution | |
| Offense | ||||
| Quarterback | A. J. McKenna | SR | Scranton, PA | Albany State University |
| Running Back | Demetric Johnson | SR | Thomson, GA | Albany State University |
| Quinn Porter | SR | Los Angeles, CA | Stillman College | |
| Wide Receiver | An’Thon Harris | JR | Atlanta, GA | Fort Valley State University |
| Antoine Mitchell | JR | Atlanta, GA | Tuskegee University | |
| Tight End | Robert Smith | SR | St. Louis, MO | Lane College |
| Offensive Lineman | Joseph Ephrem | JR | Troy, IL | Albany State University |
| Colin Cordell | SR | Douglasville, GA | Fort Valley State University | |
| Ramone Harewood | SR | Christchurch, Barbados | Morehouse College | |
| Robert Dorsey | SR | Los Angeles, CA | Tuskegee University | |
| Christopher Hymel | SR | Gramercy, LA | Stillman College | |
| Defense | ||||
| Defensive Lineman | Chris Jinks | JR | Miami, FL | Benedict College |
| Tyrell Henderson | SR | Columbus, OH | Kentucky State University | |
| Brandon Anderson | SR | Toxey, AL | Tuskegee University | |
| Junior Galette | SR | Philadelphia, PA | Stillman College | |
| Linebackers | Zimier McCloud | SR | Philadelphia, PA | Clark Atlanta University |
| Michael Thompson | SR | Springfield, OH | Benedict College | |
| Charlie Wilson | SO | Montgomery, AL | Morehouse College | |
| Defensive Back | Mario Fuller | SR | Jesup, GA | Albany State University |
| Marquez Gibson | JR | Augusta, GA | Benedict College | |
| Justin Hill | JR | Phoenix City, AL | Miles College | |
| Justin Hannah | SR | Birmingham, AL | Tuskegee University | |
| Special Teams | ||||
| Kick Returner | Jamaree Gordon | JR | Atlanta, GA | Kentucky State University |
| Punt Returner | An’Thon Harris | JR | Atlanta, GA | Fort Valley State University |
| Place Kicker | Ian Mullin | JR | Long Beach, CA | Morehouse College |
| Punter | Marquette King | SO | Macon, GA | Fort Valley State University |
2nd Team
|
Name |
CL |
Hometown |
Institution |
|
| Offense | ||||
| Quarterback | Pat Riley | JR | Attapulgus, GA | Benedict College |
| Running Back | Winston Thompson | JR | Miami, FL | Clark Atlanta University |
| Anthony Boykins | JR | Dallas, TX | Kentucky State University | |
| Wide Receiver | Ronnie Childs | JR | Manchester, GA | Albany State University |
| Achille Hendje | SR | Silver Springs, MD | Morehouse College | |
| Tight End | Rodriquez Render | JR | LaGrange, GA | Fort Valley State University |
| Offensive Lineman | Deymound Wright | SR | St. Matthews, SC | Benedict College |
| Alphonso Johnson | SR | Montgomery, AL | Clark Atlanta University | |
| Jessie Mitchell | SR | East St. Louis, IL | Kentucky State University | |
| Tocarius Ray | SR | Birmingham, AL | Miles College University | |
| Danny Daniels | SR | Hopkins, SC | Tuskegee University | |
| Defense | ||||
| Defensive Lineman | Joshua Ingram | JR | Milledgeville, GA | Albany State University |
| Marcus Winston | SR | Lansing, MI | Clark Atlanta University | |
| Robert Jackson | SR | Jonesboro, GA | Fort Valley State University | |
| Danny Anderson | SR | Butler, AL | Tuskegee University | |
| Linebackers | Jonathan Hall | SR | Mobile, AL | Tuskegee University |
| Trent Newton | SR | Lakeland, FL | Fort Valley State University | |
| William Hollis | JR | Pontiac, MI | Clark Atlanta University | |
| Defensive Back | Jonathan Armstrong | SR | Savannah, GA | Albany State University |
| Dionte’ Dickens | JR | Macon, GA | Fort Valley State University | |
| Dejuan Williams | FR | Baxley, GA | Fort Valley State University | |
| Jeremy Obie | SR | High Point, NC | Tuskegee University | |
| Special Teams | ||||
| Kick Returner | Jamar Rodriguez | JR | Houston, TX | Morehouse College |
| Punt Returner | David Grace | FR | Hawkinsville, GA | Clark Atlanta University |
| Place Kicker | Juan Bongarra | SR | Buenos Aires, Argentina | Albany State University |
| Punter | Ian Mullin | JR | Long Beach, CA | Morehouse College |
Superlatives
Offensive Player of the Year: A. J. McKenna, Albany State University
Co – Defensive Players of the Year: Justin Hannah, Tuskegee University
Zimier McCloud, Clark Atlanta University
Freshman of the Year: Dejuan Williams, Fort Valley State University
Most Valuable Player: A. J. McKenna, Albany State University
Coach of the Year: Willie Slater, Tuskegee University
